Soitenly
Moronika
The community forum of ThreeStooges.net

The Finishing Touch (1928) - Laurel and Hardy

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline metaldams

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0018890/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1
http://www.lordheath.com/index.php?p=1_157_The-Finishing-Touch
http://www.laurelandhardycentral.com/finishing.html

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Xlmghh41yWA

Watch THE FINISHING TOUCH in the link above



      One thing Laurel and Hardy and The Three Stooges have in common is whenever they are around tools comically destructive results happen.  THE FINISHING TOUCH is the first such film for Laurel and Hardy, and it is definitely a classic.  There's really not too much to say about this one because it's so simple.  The plot involves Stan and Ollie having to build a house for a man by Monday in order to earn $500.  They are doing so across the street from a hospital that involves quiet, so a pretty nurse, played by Dorothy Coburn, occasionally reprimands them, and when she's not, it is the job of a cop, played by Edgar Kennedy, to do so.  Needless to say, all involved get put in several different slapstick comedy situations that involve very little plot and very many failed attempts at building a house.

      Some random things I love about this short are Ollie putting the nails in his mouth, only to fall down in some various way and swallow them.  By the third time he does it, my reaction is, "Oh no, I can't believe he hasn't learned his lesson yet!"  I have no idea how nails digest, but for Ollie's sake, I hope easily, because if not, he's in for some pain.

      Stan Laurel gets some nice bits as well.  Watching him decimate a window sill methodically is fun, and his pantomime skills are wonderfully displayed when he fails to saw a board and keep his hat from falling off his head at the same time.  Of course, at one point the hat accidentally becomes a saw!

      There are also some nice ways gags reoccur.  For example, very early in the film their truck seems to go in reverse and cause comic mayhem, so in order to prevent this, they put a rock underneath the back tire to keep the truck still.  One of the last gags in the film, twenty minutes later, ties into this first gag very well.  There's also several shots of Ollie walking on a plank to get to the elevated porch, and Ollie has the plank break from under him resulting in some very funny falls.  The last time they do this gag in the film there is a great variation on this gag, which I won't give away.  Also, the animated bird flying into and breaking the chimney at the end?  Pure gold.  Another great bit is the super glue falling on Edgar Kennedy, followed by the planks which manage to stick to him.  He looks and moves like some slapstick FRANKENSTEIN monster.

      Overall, just a very funny, simple, and satisfying slapstick comedy with no frills.  If you want to see grown men fall down and find various ways to destroy a house, you've come to the right place.

10/10




- Doug Sarnecky


Offline metaldams

Bump, because this short is too good not to get a response.

(Assumes Paul Stanley voice). C'mawn peeeee-pull!  Now I KNOW...you can do better than this.
- Doug Sarnecky


Offline luke795

I like the first time when Stan takes the board away and then Ollie falls down and brakes the door.  Then the time when Stan takes the box away to put the window in and the Ollie falls down again with nails in his mouth.  The final time Ollie runs across the board with the door and the whole porch falls down is a great scene too.  The final scene when Stan and Ollie remove the rock from under the tire of their truck and then the truck backs into the house and destroys it is the best scene.


Offline Big Chief Apumtagribonitz

The dialog cards in this one and some others I've seen have Ollie speaking as a real roughneck.  It must have been a surprise in Unaccustomed As We Are to hear him speak in such a genteel way.


Offline metaldams

The dialog cards in this one and some others I've seen have Ollie speaking as a real roughneck.  It must have been a surprise in Unaccustomed As We Are to hear him speak in such a genteel way.

I saw a Larry Semon comedy recently, THE PERFECT CLOWN, which had Oliver Hardy as a landlord angrily trying to get his rent.  For the life of me, I could not picture the Ollie we all know and love speaking like the dialogue cards and acting like this character.  Then again, I gotta realize Ollie was a character actor in silent films at this point and not the character actor we all know.

The mannerisms from a pantomime point of view in most of these shorts feel like pure Ollie, though.
- Doug Sarnecky


Offline Big Chief Apumtagribonitz

No, Hardy didn't change anything, just the dialog cards disappeared.


Offline Paul Pain

  • Moronika's resident meteorologist
  • Bunionhead
  • ******
  • The heartthrob of millions!
I enjoyed this one quite a bit.

It was nice to see Dorothy Coburn's hospital pack up and leave.  The moment I saw the sign "Hospital Quiet" and her talking to Edgar Kennedy, I thought "She has no legal right to 'quiet' just because it's a hospital."  Stan and Ollie did a fantastic job with Stan making the tearing sound and Ollie's "16 kilometers!"

This is the same kind of destruction that makes JERKS OF ALL TRADES great.  10/10
#1 fire kibitzer


Offline Umbrella Sam

  • Toastmaster General
  • Knothead
  • *****
    • Talk About Cinema
This was definitely an improvement over LEAVE 'EM LAUGHING, thanks to the constant destruction mixed with a very interesting premise of having to do it quietly. Throw in what I considered to be LEAVE 'EM LAUGHING's highlight, Edgar Kennedy, and we get a wonderful two-reeler.

What can I add that hasn't already been said? Well, I'll start by once again giving praise to Kennedy for his presence. His reactions to Laurel and Hardy once again make for a lot of funny moments. Whether it be simple confusion from seeing Laurel with a giant piece of wood or surprise from building materials suddenly falling on him, he makes for a great occasional break from the leading comedians, who also do a very good job with the material that they have.

One thing that I really like is how it goes out of its way to build-up certain gags. For example, there's a scene where Hardy is standing on a plank trying to paint the roof and Laurel ends up cutting it. I was expecting him to cut it and for Hardy to fall down right away, but it instead shows Laurel's own struggles with both his hat and the saw. I really like that, as I think it adds a lot of build-up to this gag, as we slowly wait for the inevitable. Another good example of this is the final gag of Hardy walking on the plank to get to the porch.

Even after they finally finish the house, we still get treated to one final fight, in which Laurel and Hardy try to keep the money away from the owner through various means, including playing a game of football with it, ending in even more destruction than expected. I was laughing throughout and am looking forward to more in the future.

10 out of 10
“I’ll take a milkshake...with sour milk!” -Shemp (Punchy Cowpunchers, 1950)

My blog: https://talk-about-cinema.blogspot.com


Offline metaldams

This was definitely an improvement over LEAVE 'EM LAUGHING, thanks to the constant destruction mixed with a very interesting premise of having to do it quietly. Throw in what I considered to be LEAVE 'EM LAUGHING's highlight, Edgar Kennedy, and we get a wonderful two-reeler.

What can I add that hasn't already been said? Well, I'll start by once again giving praise to Kennedy for his presence. His reactions to Laurel and Hardy once again make for a lot of funny moments. Whether it be simple confusion from seeing Laurel with a giant piece of wood or surprise from building materials suddenly falling on him, he makes for a great occasional break from the leading comedians, who also do a very good job with the material that they have.

One thing that I really like is how it goes out of its way to build-up certain gags. For example, there's a scene where Hardy is standing on a plank trying to paint the roof and Laurel ends up cutting it. I was expecting him to cut it and for Hardy to fall down right away, but it instead shows Laurel's own struggles with both his hat and the saw. I really like that, as I think it adds a lot of build-up to this gag, as we slowly wait for the inevitable. Another good example of this is the final gag of Hardy walking on the plank to get to the porch.

Even after they finally finish the house, we still get treated to one final fight, in which Laurel and Hardy try to keep the money away from the owner through various means, including playing a game of football with it, ending in even more destruction than expected. I was laughing throughout and am looking forward to more in the future.

10 out of 10

Nice review.  I may get back to these sometime in the future, but not at the moment.  In the mean time, Laurel and Hardy + hammer and nails = funny.  Pretty much an equation that should be taught to all school children.
- Doug Sarnecky


Offline Dr. Mabuse

Destructive slapstick in the classic Laurel and Hardy tradition. "The Finishing Touch" finds Stan and Ollie in good form, with the added pleasure of Edgar Kennedy's frustrated cop. An enjoyable precursor to the 1933 two-reeler "Busy Bodies," even though the climactic gag falls flat. One of the few L&H shorts directed by Clyde Bruckman.

8.5/10


Offline HomokHarcos

Laurel and Hardy films can often be divided by  different types, such as the domestic comedies that are like The Honeymooners, and the workplace comedies like The Three Stooges. I happen to love Laurel and Hardy's workplace comedies where they cause havoc. In this case you can't really blame Stan and Ollie. Their boss wants them to build a house in only a few days! This is one of the greatest Laurel and Hardy shorts, and one of the greatest silent comedies in general. I wish we still had this type of comedy today. Really, The Three Stooges were the only major act to break through in the sound era that were like this.

Of course, the ending is great. Stan and Ollie are about to get paid, but then the building falls apart! This short reminds me of One Week with Buster Keaton, building a house quickly only for it to be messed up. Even the car smashing through the building is similar to the train hitting the house.



Offline metaldams

There’s gotta be more hammer and nail comedians other than The Three Stooges post Stan and Ollie, but I’m having trouble thinking of them.  I do know Shemp at Vitaphone made one with Roscoe Ates....but then again, Shemp is Stooge pedigree.
- Doug Sarnecky


Offline Paul Pain

  • Moronika's resident meteorologist
  • Bunionhead
  • ******
  • The heartthrob of millions!
There’s gotta be more hammer and nail comedians other than The Three Stooges post Stan and Ollie, but I’m having trouble thinking of them.  I do know Shemp at Vitaphone made one with Roscoe Ates....but then again, Shemp is Stooge pedigree.

Wally Vernon & Eddie Quillan can get into this area as can Schilling & Lane.
#1 fire kibitzer