Moronika
The community forum of ThreeStooges.net

Recent Posts

1
General Discussion / Larry Semon appreciation thread
« Last post by falsealarms on December 02, 2024, 07:14:38 PM »
Many years ago, I heard an interview with Moe where he mentioned Larry Semon in passing as a "great comedian."

But until last week, I had never seen any of Semon's films. The Vitagraph Comedy Collection Blu-ray rectified that.

To say the Semon films on that set left an impression on me would be an understatement.

I didn't know what to expect and went in with no expectations. But I was often blown away by Semon, particularly in films like The Grocery Clerk, The Bell Hop, and The Head Waiter.

The frenetic pacing, the physical comedy, the energy, and the extravagant gags, leave no wonder as to why Semon was popular in his time.

I've seen all the Keaton silents, including those with Arbuckle, along with several of the Chaplin Mutuals, a couple Langdon silents, a few Lloyd silents, and some of the silent Laurel & Hardys.

To me, Semon at his best can stand head to head with any of those.

Now, I'm eager to see more of his work. Restored versions of some of his other shorts, like The Rent Collector, The Bakery, and The Show, show up on Flicker Alley's Laurel or Hardy set.

Anyone else here a Semon fan?

It would have been interesting to see what he might have done in the sound era had he lived that long.
2
General Discussion / Re: Stooges in serious roles
« Last post by Desmond Of The Outer Sanctorum on December 02, 2024, 05:19:46 PM »
If that torture rack scene involves Besser and he says, “Not so hard!” - I’m definitely seeking it out.
Actually, his character is described as being stoic and taking the torture like a man. Thus the relevance to "dramatic acting." Playing against type, if you will. That's what makes me want to see it.
3
General Discussion / Re: The New SHEMP BOOK
« Last post by Big Chief Apumtagribonitz on December 02, 2024, 04:23:36 PM »
And I don't want to beat a dead horse, but I just thought of this: even if Moe had seriously considered Mantan, which I don't believe,  and asked Columbia to consider him seriously, I would guess that at that point management would have asked, why Mantan when we've got our own Mantan right here on property in Dudley Dickerson?  Especially since Dudley had already made his bones with the Stooges and Hugh Herbert.  They got Joe Besser later because he was under contract, Dudley might not have been under the same kind of contract, but he obviously could have slid right into place, certainly easier contractually than Mantan, whom I don't want to diss at all, I think he was great.  And of course it is impossible to deny racism here.
4
Stooges DVD/VHS/Home Video / Re: Charley Chase 1927 silents DVD/Blu-ray forthcoming
« Last post by Dr. Mabuse on December 02, 2024, 01:44:15 PM »
Though the first reel remains lost, it was great to finally see Charley's "Now I'll Tell One" — not to mention the separate appearances of Stan and Ollie.  Another gem was the British print of "The Way of All Pants." Looking forward to the 1928 set.
5
Stooges DVD/VHS/Home Video / Re: Three Stooges shorts coming to Blu-ray this summer
« Last post by QuinceHead on December 02, 2024, 09:41:59 AM »
Today I noticed that this set is currently on sale for $94.99 on Amazon, which works out to about $1 per short, plus $5 for all the bonus extras…
6
General Discussion / Re: The New SHEMP BOOK
« Last post by QuinceHead on December 02, 2024, 07:15:11 AM »
My fellow chowderheads —

Heads up that this new Shemp biography is currently available on Hamilton Books for $24.95 plus S&H!

https://www.hamiltonbook.com/shemp-the-biography-of-the-three-stooges-shemp-howard-the-face-of-film-comedy-hardbound

For duty and humanity,
JohnH aka QuinceHead

EDIT: Whoops — looks like the book’s backordered already!  :P
7
The Three Stooges - Curly Years / Re: Crash Goes the Hash (1944)
« Last post by Larrys#1 on December 01, 2024, 09:49:46 PM »
I was watching this short the other day with my family (who aren't even stooge fans, btw) because it was Thanksgiving and well.... it had a turkey in it! This short brought nothing but smiles and laughter to all of us! This really hit me how I've taken this short for granted. I've always loved this one but it never really occurred to me how absolutely great and perfect this short is!

First, the jokes and gags here are really funny. Bud telling the stooges that he reminds him of The Three Stooges is a rather unique and shocking joke! Not something you hear in any other short.

Also, like metaldams said, the stooges become high society men. And Curly delivers an amazing performance here. The lemonade bit was absolutely hilarious.. from obliviously spilling the lemonade on the woman, then handling the ice with his hands and then using a huge ice tong which is meant for a big block of ice; not for ice cubes! And Larry, although his part is rather small in the short, gives one of his finest performances where he tries to take a picture of the Prince and then falls into the piano, and just comes up and says, "it fall down!." After that bit, he accidentally steps on Van Bustle's skirt causing it tear off. Then she pulls it from Larry's foot causing Larry to fall smack on his back! I wonder how Larry pulled off that stunt without a stuntman! He must be more talented than I thought!

And I agree with metaldams,  Victor Travers' reaction to the masked potatoes in his face and also the peas and crackers getting thrown at him were priceless!

And of course, the whole turkey scene was hilarious as well!
8
I know that W & W were successful Broadway comedians, but nowadays they more resemble a couple of cheapo Burlesque comics, especially in the pre-code stuff like this one.  It seems like a warmup to a striptease, with Woolsey's cigar puffing and the checkered suits, and well, just everything.  There's a tackiness to the routines, and it's the same on everything of theirs that I've seen to date, especially So This Is Africa.  They're like lame dirty jokes which just kind of peter out, no pun intended.  I actually enjoy the musical numbers they do, they nail those, but I'm not a fan of the verbal routines at all.
9
Stooges DVD/VHS/Home Video / Re: Our Gang silents being prepped for DVD/Blu Ray
« Last post by Tony Bensley on November 29, 2024, 05:45:45 PM »
Yea, I don't know how youtube determine what frame of a video to display as a "teaser", but the angle and the fact that the "L" is a bit light creates the illusion. I can't unsee it -- if you look quickly, or not directly focused on it it says "Vietnam" to me.
I can definitely see it.
10
Stooges DVD/VHS/Home Video / Re: Charley Chase 1927 silents DVD/Blu-ray forthcoming
« Last post by NoahYoung on November 29, 2024, 03:07:27 PM »
Interested to hear how the rest are.

I suppose the next release will contain all of 1928, and LIMOUSINE LOVE will finally be available in any video format in the U.S. (It was released on 16mm, though.) I know they're going in order, but I would have included it as a bonus on one of the prior discs lest they never release a 1928 set. The forces of nature seem to not want LIMOUSINE LOVE released and I'm glad I downloaded a copy from the tube while it was available.