Topic: Same short different title/Same short different stooge

[CURLYFAN]

I noticed that there are a few shorts that are basically the same  buy have different titles like "Hot Ice" is the same short as another but it has a few different scenes.
"Nobody looks dapper in here"

I also noticed that a few shorts are the same except that the 3rd stooge is different.
They did one short with shemp and they did it again with joe besser, I believe Moe swallowed tacks and Shemp/Joe said "Maybe their income tax"

I wish that I could remember titles but I have 11 video tapes of the 3 stooges and I haven't wrote doown the titles of each short yet.

[stoogesarepimp]

Some shorts were similar except for the 3rd stooge.  None were exactly similar but they had a small similarity.

[doughhead]

 I beleive "Hot Ice" was a remake of "crime On Their Hands".

[CURLYFAN]

I believe they did and episode with SHEMP and later did a remake with JOE BESSER.

The only thing I remember about it was MOE swallowing tacks SHEMP/JOE saying "Maybe their income tax" they were re-upholstering a couch with rifle.

[jaronson]

Here's a list of all shorts and their remakes:

1. HOI POLLOI (Curly), HALF-WITS HOLIDAY (Curly), PIES AND GUYS (Joe)
2. ANTS IN THE PANTRY, THE PEST MAN WINS
3. HEALTHY, WEALTHY, AND DUMB; A MISSED FORTUNE
4. THREE DUMB CLUCKS, UP IN DAISY'S PENTHOUSE
5. A PLUMBING WE WILL GO (Curly), VAGABOND LOAFERS (Shemp), SCHEMING SCHEMERS (Shemp)
6. FRIGHT NIGHT, FLING IN THE RING
7. OUT WEST, PALS AND GALS
*8. HOLD THAT LION!, LOOSE LOOT, BOOTY AND THE BEAST
9. BRIDELESS GROOM, HUSBANDS BEWARE
10. SING A SONG OF SIX PANTS; RIP, SEW, AND STITCH
11. ALL GUMMED UP, BUBBLE TROUBLE
12. SHIVERING SHERLOCKS, OF CASH AND HASH
13. PARDON MY CLUTCH, WHAM-BAM-SLAM
14. SQUAREHEADS OF THE ROUND TABLE, KNUTZY KNIGHTS
15. FIDDLER'S THREE, MUSTY MUSKETEERS
16. HOT SCOTS, SCOTCHED IN SCOTLAND
17. HEAVENLY DAZE, BEDLAM IN PARADISE
18. I'M A MONKEY'S UNCLE, STONE AGE ROMEOS
19. CRIME ON THEIR HANDS, HOT ICE
20. THE GHOST TALKS, CREEPS
21. WHO DONE IT?, FOR CRIMIN' OUT LOUD
22. HOKUS POCUS, FLAGPOLE JITTERS
23. FUELIN' AROUND, HOT STUFF
24. MALICE IN THE PALACE, RUMPUS IN THE HAREM
25. DUNKED IN THE DEEP, COMMOTION ON THE OCEAN
26. OILY TO BED, OILY TO RISE (Curly); OIL'S WELL THAT ENDS WELL (Joe) (partial remake)
27. LOVE AT FIRST BITE, FIFI BLOWS HER TOP (partial remake)
28. PHONY EXPRESS (Curly), MERRY MAVERICKS (Shemp) (partial remake)
29. CORNY CASANOVAS, RUSTY ROMEOS
30. HE COOKED HIS GOOSE, TRIPLE CROSSED
31. WHAT'S THE MATADOR?, SAPPY BULLFIGHTERS
32. IDIOTS' DELUXE, GUNS A POPPIN'

*= HOLD THAT LION! had two separate remakes
2-4: Original is with Curly, Remake is with Shemp
6-25: Original and Remake are both with Shemp
29-30: Original is with Shemp, Remake is with Joe
31-32: Original is with Curly, Remake is with Joe

Hope this list helps.  If I left any out, just add what I missed to the list.

[Dunrobin]

That's a great list, and an excellent reason to add aother feature to the site. 

You'll now find a Stooges Remakes page under Stooge Info on the site menu.  (And yes, the page is updateable by Team Stooge members, so if you think of more you can add them.)
Kudos to jaronson for inspiring a new feature!  :wav: