I watched this yesterday since I just received a Super 8 print a few days ago.
I haven't watched "A Plumbing We Will Go" in a while, so I won't compare.
This was a very funny short -- easily one of the best Shemps. I laughed out loud a few times. I notice that when I haven't watched many Stooges shorts in a while that I find them funnier, but I suppose that that goes for just about any of the comedians. I'm also more focused when I watched them on film rather than on video. It's much more involving for me -- but that's an entirely different topic for a different day.
Since they got Dudley Dickerson anyway, I'm not sure why they just didn't have him re-enact his old scenes -- or create some new gags with him in the kitchen.
BTW, when I google the name of this short, I found this!
https://www.vagabond.com/us/men/footwear/loafers/