Topic: What are your top 10 Shemp shorts?

[Squirrelbait]

Since we've been discussing the Shemp shorts on a weekly basis now, what would you consider to be your ten favorites?

*My list would be:

Self-Made Maids
Goof On The Roof
Scrambled Brains
Heavenly Daze
Brideless Groom
Who Done It?
Three Dark Horses
Listen Judge
The Tooth Will Out
Dopey Dicks

*Not really in any particular order, aside from Self-Made Maids.

[metaldams]

Top 10 may be a bit hard, especially since I have not watched most of these shorts in over two years.  I really like the majority of those shorts, but SELF-MADE MAIDS?  I hope you contribute when we get to that one, because there'll be some counter opinions for sure!

[Squirrelbait]

Top 10 may be a bit hard, especially since I have not watched most of these shorts in over two years.  I really like the majority of those shorts, but SELF-MADE MAIDS?  I hope you contribute when we get to that one, because there'll be some counter opinions for sure!

Yeah, call me an oddball, but that's always been my number one favorite Shemp short. It's just so different, and it always cracks me up. I'll be there for sure!

[stoogerascalfan62]

So far I can only think of Sing A Song Of Six Pants, Out West, Dunked In The Deep, and Listen, Judge.

[Paul Pain]

I am going to burn the tinfoil hat here.  No need for it.  I have nothing controversial to say here, but on the discussions, well...
No particular order here.

THREE ARABIAN NUTS
THREE DARK HORSES
BLUNDER BOYS
SCRAMBLED BRAINS
INCOME TAX SAPPY
PARDON MY CLUTCH
PARDON MY BACKFIRE
FUELIN' AROUND
MALICE IN THE PALACE
TRICKY DICKS

[Lefty]

In chronological order:

Squareheads of the Round Table
Dunked in the Deep
Three Arabian Nuts
Don't Throw That Knife
The Tooth Will Out
Listen Judge
Three Dark Horses
Pardon My Backfire
Shot in the Frontier
Gypped in the Penthouse

[Shemp_Diesel]

Blunder Boys
Brideless Groom
Scrambled Brains
Three Dark Horses
Who Done It?
Heavenly Daze
Corny Casanovas
Gents in a Jam
Tricky Dicks
Up In Daisy's Penthouse

[archiezappa]

In no particular order:

Brideless Groom
Sing A Song Of Six Pants
Tricky Dicks
All Gummed Up
Blunder Boys
The Tooth Will Out
Malice In The Palace
The Ghost Talks
Love At First Bite
I'm A Monkey's Uncle

But don't get me wrong.  I love them all.

[Squirrelbait]

I forgot about Blunder Boys - just about everyone else added that one to their list. Definitely a great one!

[Woe-ee-Woe-Woe80]

My Top 10 favorite Shemp shorts are in no particular order

Gents In A Jam
Pardon My Backfire (nice to see some love towards that short)
Scrambled Brains
Who Done It
Brideless Groom
Goof On The Roof
Slaphappy Sleuths (another underrated short)
Three Arabian Nuts
Three Dark Horses
Corny Casanovas

Honorable mention

Three Hams On Rye
Sing A Song Of Six Pants
Hold That Lion
Fuelin' Around

[Umbrella Sam]

It’s been a while, but from memory, this would probably be my top 10:
THREE DARK HORSES
SQUAREHEADS OF THE ROUND TABLE
PUNCHY COWPUNCHERS
LISTEN, JUDGE
THE TOOTH WILL OUT
TRICKY DICKS
BRIDELESS GROOM
HEAVENLY DAZE
CRIME ON THEIR HANDS
BLUNDER BOYS

Honorable mentions:
DOPEY DICKS
STUDIO STOOPS
WHO DONE IT?

[metaldams]

Bump

[Dr. Mabuse]

Hold That Lion! (1947)
Brideless Groom (1947)
All Gummed Up (1947)
Heavenly Daze (1948)
Crime on Their Hands (1948)
Who Done It? (1949)
Fuelin’ Around (1949)
Malice in the Palace (1949)
Hula-La-La (1951)
Shot in the Frontier (1954)

[metaldams]

1. Dopey Dicks
2. Three Arabian Nuts
3. Who Done It?
4. Brideless Groom
5. Scrambled Brains
6. Corny Casanovas
7. Goof on the Roof
8. Squareheads of the Round Table
9. Hugs and Mugs
10. Heavenly Daze