METALDAMS SHORTS TOURNAMENT

Rich Finegan · **Reply #25 on:** September 14, 2010, 04:04:16 AM

Hoi Polloi

Very hard to select just one!
But although it's a great one with many classic scenes, I always thought the end scene of "Three Little Beers" was a big let-down. Such a lame gag after such a great short.
"An Ache in Every Stake" - also lots of great classic scenes: the stairway, the bowling with the ice blocks, the kitchen scenes, especially Curly shaving the ice. But I had to go with:
"Hoi Polloi" -- The Winner! Again, lots of great stuff. Plus the bonus of a good incidental music score, and perhaps my favorite Stooges short of one of my favorite supporting players, Phyllis Crane.

PSUStooge · **Reply #26 on:** September 14, 2010, 05:19:25 PM

Hoi Polloi

I think "Ache" probably has this in the bag, but I admit to preferring the other two shorts in the finals myself. "Three Little Beers" is a full fledged gem, but I think "Hoi Polloi" is just a quintessential stooge short. Every gag in it works, and it represents the clash of the social classes at the time perfectly. You could put this one in a time capsule, play it 100 years later, and it will still represent everything that the boys loved and stood for.

Of course, I could probably say that about at least thirty other shorts. Either way..."Polloi" is the one I enjoy the most out of the three choices.

metaldams · **Reply #27 on:** September 14, 2010, 06:49:17 PM

It's Ache 9, Hoi 7, Beers 6 (somebody double check that for me)

It's still close, so let's get more votes coming in.

shemps#1 · **Reply #28 on:** September 14, 2010, 11:37:44 PM

Yep that's right...controversy abound as the winner could very well not have the majority of votes.

Stanley Blystone · **Reply #29 on:** September 15, 2010, 12:41:21 AM

An Ache in Every Stake

"I told you to be careful!" - Bud Jamison to Vernon Dent after Curly knocks over Vernon and he falls face first on his birthday cake.

Bud_Jamison · **Reply #30 on:** September 15, 2010, 06:35:55 PM

OK,

Just watched all three again (with a nice single malt - breath of heather) I can't argue against any of you who choose "Ache". It is really a masterpiece on all counts. So is Three Little Beers but as another poster mentioned, it does have a weak end after the barrel scenes & Bud really carries the open with a great performance. But Hoi-Polloi gets my vote.

Hoi Polloi

Why has no one made mention of the great Del Lord and the fact that all of these are his shorts?

metaldams · **Reply #31 on:** September 15, 2010, 09:57:22 PM

Quote from: Bud_Jamison on September 15, 2010, 06:35:55 PM

Why has no one made mention of the great Del Lord and the fact that all of these are his shorts?

Priase Del Lord! (I can't take credit for that one, there is a poster on here with that name I saw once, but I don't think he ever posted. Still, best user name ever).

I would consider Del Lord the best Stooge director, though.

metaldams · **Reply #32 on:** September 15, 2010, 10:23:58 PM

ACHE 10, HOI 8, BEERS 6

Let's keep those votes coming! I want at least 30, we only have 24.

By the way, if AN ACHE IN EVERY STAKE wins, it will be the first short be be a two-time champion.

metaldams · **Reply #33 on:** September 18, 2010, 08:32:24 AM

Just to make it official, AN ACHE IN EVERY STAKE is the winner. Thank you to everybody who voted, you guys rock.

xraffle · **Reply #34 on:** September 18, 2010, 10:32:48 AM

I'm disappointed in the results. Yeah, "An Ache In Every Stake" is a great short, no doubt. But I wouldn't go as far as saying it's the #1 best stooge short.

shemps#1 · **Reply #35 on:** September 18, 2010, 11:26:00 AM

Well I don't think most of the people who voted for Ache would call it their favorite short. Like me, their absolute favorites were probably gone. What I'm curious about is if you took Beers out the equation would the people who voted for Beers vote for Ache or Polloi? If Polloi was taken out would the people who voted for Polloi vote for Ache or Beers?

Rhinosaurus · **Reply #36 on:** September 18, 2010, 01:13:22 PM

The Sitter Downers

........oh, its over

pipboytaylor · **Reply #37 on:** September 18, 2010, 08:05:48 PM

I was one of the 6 "Beer" voters. I would have voted for "Ache" over "Polloi". My favorite short is "Who Done It?."

afcomser · **Reply #38 on:** September 21, 2010, 03:19:20 AM

Three Little Beers

Paul Pain · **Reply #39 on:** January 10, 2017, 05:24:42 PM

Would anyone be interested in doing something like this again? It'd be fun and the first time in almost 7 years.

CurlyFan1934 · **Reply #40 on:** January 10, 2017, 07:13:07 PM

Quote from: Paul Pain on January 10, 2017, 05:24:42 PM

Would anyone be interested in doing something like this again? It'd be fun and the first time in almost 7 years.

I would be interested!

Shemp Shady · **Reply #41 on:** January 11, 2017, 01:11:46 AM

I'm also up for it -- haven't posted here in ages.

metaldams · **Reply #42 on:** January 11, 2017, 10:12:07 AM

I may do it somtime in the future, but please keep in mind I'm just about to end almost four years worth of weekly reviews and can use a little break from organizing new things. I do appreciate the interest, though.

Paul Pain · **Reply #43 on:** January 11, 2017, 10:20:36 AM

Quote from: metaldams on January 11, 2017, 10:12:07 AM

I may do it somtime in the future, but please keep in mind I'm just about to end almost four years worth of weekly reviews and can use a little break from organizing new things. I do appreciate the interest, though.

Whoever said you'd have to organize it? You have a ready volunteer

metaldams · **Reply #44 on:** January 11, 2017, 08:53:32 PM

Quote from: Paul Pain on January 11, 2017, 10:20:36 AM

Whoever said you'd have to organize it? You have a ready volunteer

This volunteer can then go ahead. I'll participate.

Paul Pain · **Reply #45 on:** January 12, 2017, 04:43:27 AM

Quote from: metaldams on January 11, 2017, 08:53:32 PM

This volunteer can then go ahead. I'll participate.

I will probably do it in the regular short-reviews section or general discussion as I haven't the ability to start topics here. People are more likely to see it there anyway.

METALDAMS SHORTS TOURNAMENT - THE FINALS

xraffle