Sorry to bump this old thread -- I have been curious about this trailer since I first saw it as an extra on the "Men Behind The Mayhem" DVD. So this was a trailer for a local/regional presentation, even specifically for one theater then. Do we know what theater it was? Is the 1953 year accurate?
I suppose at this late date it's not possible to research what was included in this show. Besides a selection of Stooge shorts (which I would guess were all with Shemp, but who knows), it says there were a bunch of cartoons, and I suppose there is no guarantee that they would necessarily have been Columbia cartoons, they could have been anything.